>> SLIDE 1 Chemical Sensitivities: Select Federal Policies, Programs, and Practices & Access and Accommodation in Housing and the Workplace IL Conversation August 10, 2011 Mary Lamielle, Executive Director National Center for Environmental Health Strategies, Inc. 1100 Rural Avenue Voorhees, New Jersey 08043 (856)429-5358; (856)816-8820 marylamielle@ncehs.org >> SLIDE 2 OVERVIEW -Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) & Indoor Environmental Quality (IEQ) -Federal Agency Recognition of CS; Federal Policies, Programs, and Practices -Access & Accommodations: housing & the workplace -NCEHS Advocacy Initiatives >> SLIDE 3 The TEAM (Total Exposure Assessment Methodology) Study: five year EPA study that found indoor environments more toxic than outdoor air for specific volatile organic chemicals Indoor Air Quality (IAQ); Indoor Environmental Quality (IEQ) Healthy, Accessible Environments: home, school, workplace, public and commercial buildings, and the community Indoor Air Quality Act of 1989 >> SLIDE 4 Federal Recognition of CS -Social Security Administration, February 1988 -Program Operations Manual --Department of Housing and Urban Development , April 14, 1992 --Legal Memorandum recognizing MCS/EI as “handicaps” under the Fair Housing Act entitling reasonable accommodations on a case by case basis --Excludes allergies -Extends coverage to those recognized as disabled by Social Security Administration -Lists other federal agencies recognize MCS -Department of Education -Civil Rights Division, U.S. Department of Justice --Americans with Disabilities Act Guidelines, July 26, 1991 Those severely affected by MCS "will satisfy the requirements to be considered disabled under the regulation." Federal Register, Vol. 56, No. 144, pp. 35549, 35699. >> SLIDE 5 U.S. Access Board -1999 Holds training for Board and staff on fragrances -2000 Adopts Fragrance-Free Policy for Board Meetings http://www.access-board.gov/about/meetings.htm -2000 Creates committee to examine CS/ES -2003;2007 Contracts with National Institute of Building Sciences to study indoor environmental quality (IEQ) and CS/ES -2006 Issues “Indoor Environmental Quality Project Report” www.access-board.gov/research/ieq -2010 Opens permanent meeting space designated fragrance-free: all participants refrain from perfume and cologne; unscented personal care products; scent-free cleaning and maintenance (July 2010) >> SLIDE 6 Image: button reads "Perfume Pollutes: NCEHS - www.ncehs.org >> SLIDE 7 Federal Action on Fragrances CDC Indoor Environmental Quality Policy, June 2009 Fragrance-Free Policy “Scented or fragranced products are prohibited at all times in all interior space owned, rented, or leased by CDC.” (p. 9) “Fragrance is not appropriate for a professional work environment, and the use of some products with fragrance may be detrimental to the health of workers with chemical sensitivities, allergies, asthma, and chronic headaches/migraines.” (p. 9) >> SLIDE 8 CDC Non-Permissible Products -Incense, candles, or reed diffusers -Fragrance-emitting devices of any kind -Wall-mounted devices, similar to fragrance-emitting devices, that operate automatically or by pushing a button to dispense deodorizers or disinfectants -Potpourri -Plug-in or spray air fresheners -Urinal or toilet blocks -Other fragranced deodorizer/re-odorizer products >> SLIDE 9 Federal Action on Fragrances U. S. Census Bureau, March 2009 -Issued fragrance-free policy and implementing language to protect employees and accommodate disabled workers Department of Health and Human Services, October 10, 2010 -Based on CDC policy: Identical list of non-permissible products; -restricts application of fragranced products at work; exempts fitness centers and day-care centers FEMA -Blanket purchase orders for medical supplies require products to be latex and fragrance-free >> SLIDE 10 NCEHS Fragrance-Free Proposals -White House Disability Policy Office -GSA -FEMA --FEMA proposal includes a fragrance-free policy for personal care products and cleaning and maintenance supplies for emergency management and disaster relief >> SLIDE 11 Model Fragrance-Free Policy This is a Fragrance-Free Workplace We Share the Air Please refrain from wearing (using) perfume, cologne, aftershave, or other fragranced, scented, or odorous personal care or laundry products including shampoo, hairspray, hair care product, hand lotion, laundry detergent and dryer sheets for the health and comfort of employees and visitors. Thank you for your consideration. >> SLIDE 12 Housing Problems -Crisis of homelessness: population of environmental refugees -Challenge: sustain life and health; life is about survival on a day-to-day basis -Serious lack of accessible, affordable, healthy/nontoxic housing -Failure to accommodate in existing housing -Failure of multi-family or integrated housing to work for those disabled by CS/ES -Extreme problems with harassment, discrimination, and retaliation >> SLIDE 13 US HUD Recognition of CS October 26, 1990: Policy Statement -Recognition of the disability -Reasonable accommodations for those disabled under the Fair Housing Act and Rehabilitation Act of 1973 June 6, 1991: Draft Technical Guidance Memorandum 91-3 -Discusses HUD recognition of CS as a handicap -Provides examples of accommodations which are considered reasonable (re: carpeting, pesticides) April 14, 1992: HUD Legal Memorandum -Recognition of CS/EI as a physical disability entitling reasonable accommodations on a case-by-case basis -Excludes allergies -Extends coverage to those recognized as disabled by the Social Security Administration -Lists other federal agencies that recognize CS 1992 HUD Section 811 Program allocated $700,000 to Marin Homes for Independent Living for construction of Ecology House >> SLIDE 14 Housing Accommodation Requests -Eliminate the use of structural (indoor) and landscape (outdoor) pesticides. Adopt Integrated Pest Management (IPM). -Replace gas or propane stove and/or clothes dryer with electric units. -Install washer and dryer in housing unit to eliminate the need to use common laundry areas. -Flooring: Do not install new carpeting; or remove carpeting only as necessary for tenant; or leave old carpeting untouched; or install hard surface flooring. -Retrofit inoperable windows so they can be opened. >> SLIDE 15 -Clean ductwork for heating and air conditioning systems. -Construct or replace ramps, balconies, and decks with materials well-tolerated by tenant. -Provide an extra room or bedroom for those with CS/ES to enable the tenant to isolate problematic belongings. -Avoid remodeling activities such as painting in the living area or vicinity of those with CS. If such activity is critical, arrangements must be made well in advance to house the affected individual for the length of time necessary to protect from further injury. Involve tenant in selection of least toxic/problematic products. -Designate nonsmoking homes and buildings. Post no smoking signs in common areas and in the vicinity of building entrances, windows, and air intakes. >> SLIDE 16 -Post signs to prohibit idling in parking areas. -Consult with CS tenants and their representatives for safer remodeling and maintenance practices. -Post a non-discrimination policy to protect those with CS/ES. -Eliminate or discourage the use of toxic chemicals such as pesticides, air fresheners, scented candles, etc. by other tenants. -Use least toxic/problematic cleaning products in common areas. -Discourage the use of cell phones, microwaves, fluorescent lighting and other sources of EMFs in the vicinity of those with ES. >> SLIDE 17 -Provide prenotification of building events such as cleaning, painting, roofing, and similar activities. Use the least toxic materials in consultation with the affected tenant. -Management should educate staff and tenants regarding the goal of maintaining a pollution-free environment to the extent possible for the health and well-being of all tenants. >> SLIDE 18 -Pesticides & Chemical Sensitivities: Federal Action on Pesticides & IPM --EPA Promotes Integrated Pest Management (IPM) -Food Quality Protection Act of 1996 -EPA restricts use of chlorpyrifos June 8, 2000 “IPM in Multi-Family Housing Maintenance Training Manual”, 2009 -HUD PIH 2011-22, April 26, 2011, Promotion of Integrated Pest Management (IPM) as an environmentally sound, economical and effective means to address a major resident concern -HUD PIH-2009-21 (HA), July 17, 2009, Non-Smoking Policies in Public Housing >> SLIDE 19 NCEHS Recommendations for HUD Action to Meet Housing Needs for Persons with Chemical & Electrical Sensitivities 1. A needs assessment by HUD including initiatives to create effective design and data collection for housing for persons with C/ES. 2. Fully accessible housing including 811 housing projects, Section 8 Home Ownership, and rehabilitation of existing housing stock for persons with C/ES 3. Segregated or separate and protected housing that meets accessibility needs for persons with C/ES 4. HUD funded mandatory education and training on the housing needs of persons with C/ES >> SLIDE 20 Similar recommendations -National Council on Disability, “The State of Housing in America in the 21st Century: A Disability Perspective,” January 19, 2010 -Testimony of Kelly Buckland, NCIL, Subcommittee on Housing and Community Opportunity, “The Inclusive Home Design Act,” September 29, 2010 -Housing Position Paper, NCIL Housing Subcommittee, 2003; updated May 2009 >> SLIDE 21 EEOC has tracked CS charges since 1993. 2001: A decade after the ADA, CS charges for failure to accommodate nearly double all other charges. CS lower rate of resolution than other charges. Not yet litigated. FY2010: 74 CS Charges; 11 Resolved (.2%); 8 with total monetary benefit totaling $102,925 (from total of 3,815 people benefiting for $76,123,463) http://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/statistics/enforcement/ada.cfm >> SLIDE 22 Workplace Policies -No smoking policy -Fragrance-Free policy -IPM policy to eliminate conventional pesticides; use low impact only -Notification policy -Vehicle idling policy -Cell phone use policy >> SLIDE 23 Workplace Accommodations for CS -Workplace free of tobacco smoke, pesticides, fragrances/fragranced products, and toxic cleaning products -Private office with a window that opens -Retrofit windows to make them operable -Increase fresh air supply and ventilation -Remove carpeting in favor of hard surface flooring -Move office equipment from immediate work environment of CS -Use odorless/nontoxic cleaning products -Do not use air fresheners, deodorizers, disinfectants which contaminate workplace -Provide CS employee with cleaning schedule or the option to clean and maintain own workspace -Select least toxic/allergenic/unscented construction and maintenance materials, furnishings and supplies -Off gas all new materials, furnishings and supplies before installation -Ask affected employee to check the suitability of items before use in work environment >> SLIDE 24 Workplace Accommodations -Use metal desk and shelving in lieu of veneered wood or particle board (to avoid formaldehyde and solvents from finishes) -Eliminate the use of conventional pesticides indoors and outdoors -If low impact pesticides are used, provide prenotification and post permanent notices at building entrances noting the last date of pesticide used, name of applicator, product and chemical name; post warning outside when pesticides are applied. -Provide prenotification of building events such as remodeling and renovation activities such as roofing, use of floor stripper or wax, or pesticide applications -Provide schedule options so that affected employee can work when fewer co-workers are present, when the ventilation is at its peak, or where the surroundings are least problematic -Provide the option to work at home -Educate management and co-workers as to the nature of the disability to avert stigma and harassment. >> SLIDE 25 Incidents of Intentional Harassment and Discrimination -Employee forbidden to use a charcoal mask or oxygen at work -Employee forbidden to open a window, even in a private office -Window(s) nailed shut to prevent opening -Signs that request a specific accommodation and name the disabled employee: -“Please refrain from the use of perfumes for Bonnie” >> SLIDE 26 Harassment and Discrimination -Intensified use of perfume or the use of perfume and other scented products during the workday -Perfume poured on CS-employee’s chair -Deodorizer sprayed on CS-employee’s phone -Intentional use of candles, incense, or potpourri -Use of cell phones or microwave ovens in the vicinity of ES employee -Employee “accommodated” by selecting worst possible/least accessible worksite: --CS employee moved into janitor’s office --Teacher with CS moved to copy center; another teacher moved into art room --ES employee moved next to an electrical transformer >> SLIDE 27 Assistive Technology, etc. -Charcoal mask, respirator, or other personal protection equipment or device -Oxygen with ceramic or stainless steel mask with tygon or stainless steel tubing -Charcoal, HEPA (high efficiency particulate air), and/or electronic air filter, or other air filtering device or equipment. -Reading Box -Localized exhaust for computers, printers, and other equipment -Low emission computers, VDT terminals, and other equipment, or shielding from electromagnetic fields -Incandescent or natural lighting in lieu of fluorescent lighting -Speaker phone or intercom system to participate in meetings, communicate with others -Assistant or errand runner who can take care of tasks that the affected employee cannot perform due to exposures >> SLIDE 28 Logo: cleaner air >> SLIDE 29 Cleaner Air Room & Paths of Travel -No smoking -Fragrance-Free -Pesticide-Free indoors and outdoors -Least toxic cleaning products -No recent construction or remodeling including carpet installation -Cell phones turned off -Ability to turn off or unplug computers and other electrical equipment -Ability to turn off fluorescent lighting -Ability to adjust temperature and air flow or availability of operable windows >> SLIDE 30 NCEHS Advocacy Initiatives -Fragrance-Free Proposals with White House Disability Policy Office, GSA, and FEMA -Recommendations for HUD to address housing needs -Interagency Committee on Chemical Sensitivities -Advancing recommendation of CDC National Conversation on Public Health and Chemical Exposures Action Agenda, June 2011 for research on CS using an Environmental Medical Unit (EMU) - http://www.nationalconversation.us/action-agenda/chapter-3-science/chapter-3-additional-recommendations -Inclusion of research recommendation on CS in National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS) Strategic Plan >> SLIDE 31 1993 Expert Panel on CS Convened by ATSDR with directed Congressional funds Recommended: -Environmental Medical Unit (EMU) for research—principal recommendation; -Interagency Committee on Chemical Sensitivities; -Neurosciences Workshop; -Research in conjunction with exposure events >> SLIDE 32 What has been accomplished over the last two decades has been: -Piecemeal -Each issue and accomplishment a battle; frequently a new battle -Don’t seem to accumulate any common knowledge >> SLIDE 33 Why Do We Need An Interagency Committee? -Collaborate and coordinate across federal agencies -Review what has been done; -Identify gaps and recommend coordinated action; -Jump start research using an Environmental Medical Unit; -Create policies and programs that address needs of affected populations >> SLIDE 34 Interagency Proposal -Supported by Access Board and HUD; -Informal support other agency personnel -Congressional request to Secretary Sebelius to establish Interagency Committee >> SLIDE 35 Mary Lamielle, Executive Director National Center for Environmental Health Strategies, Inc. 1100 Rural Avenue Voorhees, New Jersey 08043 (856)429-5358; cell (856)816-8820 marylamielle@ncehs.org www.ncehs.org >> END PRESENTATION